Question: Integrated Network Security and Infrastructure Design for Merging Company A and Company B: A Risk-Based Approach to Secure Cloud and On-Premises Integration

Expert answer

DRAFT / STUDY TIPS:

Integrated Network Security and Infrastructure Design for Merging Company A and Company B: A Risk-Based Approach to Secure Cloud and On-Premises Integration

A. Network Security and Infrastructure Problems

Company A

Network Security Problems:

1. Insufficient Segmentation: Company A operates in the financial industry, where segregation of sensitive data and systems is essential. However, insufficient segmentation across its network could expose sensitive financial data, like customer transaction histories and personal details, to unauthorized users within the organization. This lack of separation also makes it easier for attackers to move laterally within the network if they breach one area.

2. Legacy Systems: As a large, established company, Company A likely has several legacy systems that may not have received security patches or updates in recent years. These systems, which might include outdated servers, software, or applications, often have known vulnerabilities that are easily exploited by cybercriminals. Without regular security updates, legacy systems become prime targets for attackers.

Infrastructure Problems:

1. Over-Reliance on On-Premises Infrastructure: While Company A may have robust on-premises infrastructure, this model limits scalability and flexibility. The inability to scale quickly in response to changing demands or unexpected spikes in business operations can be a significant bottleneck. Cloud adoption would offer greater scalability and redundancy to address these concerns.

2. Lack of Cloud Integration: Although Company A has a large-scale infrastructure, it has not fully integrated cloud technologies, leaving opportunities for scalability, cost-efficiency, and enhanced disaster recovery. By not utilizing cloud-based services, Company A may be missing opportunities to improve business continuity and reduce overhead costs.

Company B

Network Security Problems:

1. Lack of Dedicated Cybersecurity Expertise: Company B outsources its cybersecurity, which means it lacks a dedicated internal cybersecurity team. This lack of in-house expertise makes the company vulnerable to attacks, as outsourced teams may not be as responsive or proactive in identifying and mitigating potential threats. This problem is exacerbated if the third-party team is not fully aligned with Company B’s security needs or business objectives.

2. Insecure Third-Party Connections: Company B’s reliance on third-party providers for infrastructure management creates potential security risks. The company may have limited control over the security measures of its third-party service providers, making it susceptible to data breaches or cyber-attacks that could be facilitated through these external connections.

Infrastructure Problems:

1. Limited Network Scalability: Company B, being smaller than Company A, likely has an infrastructure that is not designed to scale quickly. This limitation could become a critical challenge when the two companies merge, as Company B’s systems may not be able to handle the increased volume of data or users from Company A.

2. Inconsistent Software and Hardware Standards: Given Company B’s smaller size, its infrastructure may have a mix of old and new technologies. This inconsistency can lead to compatibility issues when integrating Company A's systems, making it difficult to achieve seamless interoperability between the two organizations.

---

B. Vulnerabilities and Risk Analysis

1. Existing Vulnerabilities:

Company A:

1. Unpatched Legacy Systems: Legacy systems that are not regularly updated present a significant security risk. These outdated systems could have known vulnerabilities (e.g., unpatched software flaws) that are easily exploited by cybercriminals.

2. Insecure Network Segmentation: If Company A does not properly segment its network into distinct zones (e.g., internal, external, DMZ), attackers who gain access to one part of the network could laterally move to other critical systems, potentially accessing sensitive financial data.

Company B:

1. Insecure Third-Party Connections: Third-party service providers may not have strong cybersecurity measures in place, which could expose Company B to attacks. If a third-party provider experiences a breach, it could result in the compromise of Company B’s network and data.

2. Weak Endpoint Security: Company B’s lack of dedicated cybersecurity expertise might lead to weak endpoint protections. Employees’ devices, such as laptops or mobile phones, could be easily infected with malware or targeted for unauthorized access if they do not have adequate security measures (e.g., firewalls, antivirus, device encryption).

2. Impact, Risk, and Likelihood:

Company A:

1. Legacy System Vulnerabilities:

   • Impact: High – Exploited vulnerabilities in legacy systems could give attackers privileged access to sensitive financial data, leading to financial losses, reputational damage, or regulatory fines.
   • Risk: High – Given that legacy systems often have known vulnerabilities and may be directly connected to other critical systems, the risk of exploitation is high.
   • Likelihood: Medium to High – The likelihood depends on how outdated the systems are and whether any security measures are in place to address known vulnerabilities.

2. Insecure Network Segmentation:

   • Impact: High – Insecure segmentation would allow attackers to access sensitive data across the network.
   • Risk: High – Poor segmentation is a common attack vector, especially if lateral movement is not well controlled.
   • Likelihood: Medium – If segmentation is weak but not entirely absent, the likelihood is moderate.

Company B:

1. Third-Party Vulnerabilities:

   • Impact: Medium to High – Attacks leveraging third-party vulnerabilities could lead to the compromise of sensitive medical or payment data.
   • Risk: High – Company B relies heavily on third-party vendors, and without stringent controls, this reliance increases the risk of a breach.
   • Likelihood: High – Many third-party services have had incidents of inadequate cybersecurity practices, increasing the likelihood of exploitation.

2. Endpoint Security Weaknesses:

   • Impact: Medium – Malware infections or unauthorized access could compromise sensitive data or systems.
   • Risk: Medium – If endpoint security is inadequate, the risk of infection or breach is substantial.
   • Likelihood: High – Given the lack of dedicated cybersecurity staff, endpoint security risks are likely to remain unaddressed.

---

C. Proposed Network Topology Diagram

A comprehensive network topology for the merged organization should include the following:

1. Core Network: Separate Company A and Company B networks, each with their own perimeter security measures (e.g., firewalls, intrusion detection systems).
2. Cloud Infrastructure: Cloud resources for scalable computing, data storage, and backup services, ensuring business continuity and disaster recovery.
3. Remote Access: A secure VPN setup for remote employees, combined with multi-factor authentication (MFA) to enhance access control.
4. Zero Trust Architecture: Every device and user, regardless of their location within the network, should be treated as untrusted until verified.

---

D. OSI Model Layer Identification

Each component in the topology can be mapped to the OSI model:

• Application Layer (Layer 7): User-facing applications, secure file sharing, cloud-based applications.
• Presentation Layer (Layer 6): Encryption protocols like SSL/TLS for data protection.
• Session Layer (Layer 5): Authentication mechanisms (e.g., OAuth, SAML) for secure user sessions.
• Transport Layer (Layer 4): Protocols like HTTPS and VPN tunnels.
• Network Layer (Layer 3): Routers, firewalls, and IP-based security.
• Data Link Layer (Layer 2): VLANs, Ethernet switches for network segmentation.
• Physical Layer (Layer 1): Physical hardware, routers, and servers.

---

E. Rationale for Network Design Changes

1. Cloud Integration:

   • Addition of Cloud Security Services: Cloud-based security solutions like AWS Shield and Azure Security Center would provide scalable protection against attacks like DDoS and advanced threats.
   • Repurposing of Legacy Systems: Legacy infrastructure should either be upgraded or replaced by modern, cloud-compatible systems that can scale and integrate securely.

2. Repurposing Redundant Systems:

   • Consolidation of Third-Party Tools: Company B’s reliance on third-party services should be reduced by moving towards integrated, cloud-based solutions where feasible. This reduces the risk associated with insecure third-party connections and lowers costs in the long term.

---

F. Secure Network Design Principles

1. Least Privilege: Implement access control based on the principle of least privilege, ensuring that users and systems have only the permissions necessary to perform their tasks.
2. Redundancy and Availability: Introduce redundant systems across the cloud and on-premises infrastructure to ensure high availability and mitigate the impact of potential system failures.

---

G. Regulatory Compliance

1. HIPAA: As Company B deals with medical data, the design must ensure that all health information is stored securely and encrypted. Access controls and audit logs must be implemented to comply with HIPAA’s security rule.
2. PCI DSS: The network design must incorporate secure payment processing mechanisms, encryption of credit card data in transit, and strong access controls to prevent unauthorized access to payment information.

---

H. Emerging Threats

1. Ransomware Attacks: With an integrated cloud environment, ransomware attacks could affect both on-premises and cloud-based systems. A multi-layered defense strategy, including backup systems and endpoint protection, should be in place.
2. Cloud Configuration Risks: Improper configuration of cloud services could expose sensitive data. Ensuring strict security protocols for cloud services (e.g., regular audits, proper access management) is essential.

---

I. Recommendations for Implementation

• Cost-Benefit Analysis: Cloud services provide a cost-effective solution for scalability, redundancy, and security, especially with the budget of $50,000.
• Justification: The network design incorporates zero trust principles, regulatory compliance, and scalability to ensure long-term security and business continuity.