Call/WhatsApp/Text: +44 20 3289 5183

Question: Tyler is a three-year old boy. He lives at home with his mother, Sam (aged 24), who describes herself as Black British.

04 Apr 2023,3:14 AM

 

CASE STUDY 1a

Tyler is a three-year old boy. He lives at home with his mother, Sam (aged 24), who describes herself as Black British. Her partner Adrian (aged 35) visits the home but is not resident there. He is not Tyler’s father, but has been together with Sam for the last two years.  

 

Sam smokes heroin on an approximately twice-weekly basis (reportedly spending £10 on each occasion). This was known to the health visitor for Tyler, and a referral was made to social care services 6 months ago. Since then, you have been holding the case but on a ‘Child-in-Need’ basis, as it was felt that owing to the support of Sam’s mother Gaynor (aged 48), Tyler was not at risk of significant harm.

 

You have received a report from another mother you work with that Sam has left drug treatment and is now injecting £10 heroin daily. You have been to the house on three occasions but cannot get in.  There is no answer from Sam’s phone. Her mother has not seen her, and Tyler was at the local nursery two days ago, but not today. You have contacted the local drug agency but they are refusing to share information outside of the fact that she is ‘still known to them’, citing General Data Protection Regulations.

 

There is a report that Tyler was seen wandering in the street alone, but only yards from his door. A neighbour called the police who attended to find Sam intoxicated and incapable of looking after Tyler. Nobody else was present at the home. You attend on an emergency basis to support the police.

 

 

a) Please identify in fluent written form which items of law, policy and good practice would be appropriate for social workers and other professionals to utilise within this case study.  

b) Please explain, why these items are of relevance and how they may be applied in practice.

c) Please analyse and appraise any ethical dilemmas and issues of discrimination and oppression which could be of relevance in this case.

 

 

 

 

CASE STUDY 1b

Charlene is 15 years old, self-identifying as of mixed Black British and White British ethnicity and has recently come into local authority care. Charlene has been staying with her current foster carers for 2 weeks. Charlene has a younger sister Emma aged 10, they do not get on and there have been occasions where Charlene has been physically aggressive towards Emma which resulted in Emma being hurt. Emma is currently in the same foster placement.

Until two weeks ago, Charlene and Emma both lived with their mother Jackie, however Jackie has had some recent involvement in selling drugs again and has received a 2-year prison sentence. Jackie has a long history of police involvement for different crimes including robbery and assault. It has come to light that Charlene has also been involved in selling drugs recently and has links to a local gang who she has been in contact with since moving into foster care. The police have some questions to ask Charlene in relation to a recent assault of another young person. Charlene has a youth justice worker who she sees weekly as part of her Youth Rehabilitation Order (YRO).

Charlene and Emma both were placed under Section 20 Children Act 1989 accommodation, as no family members could be identified to care for them at that point. The whereabouts of their father Jimmy is unknown.

There are concerns about the long-term plan for the children, now that Jackie is back in prison the local authority will need to consider the best course of action. There are ongoing discussions between professionals about whether Charlene and Emma should remain in the same placement and need to consider the options available. Professionals are also worried that Charlene is being criminally exploited and is being coerced into running drugs.

 

 

a) Please identify in fluent written form which items of law, policy and good practice would be appropriate for social workers and other professionals to utilise within this case study.  

b) Please explain, why these items are of relevance and how they may be applied in practice.

c) Please analyse and appraise any ethical dilemmas and issues of discrimination and oppression which could be of relevance in this case.

 

 

 

CASE STUDY 2a

Margaret  is a 78-year-old woman of Irish origin, who was previously married but on losing her husband to a heart attack has lived alone for the past 10 years. Margaret lives in a 3 bedroom semi-detached house on the outskirts of town where unfortunately the local bus service, which used to come past her house, has now been withdrawn due to funding issues. Margaret has 2 daughters, one who lives locally (Caitlin) and the other (Jacqui) who lives in London. Both daughters have caring responsibilities and it is only the younger daughter Caitlin who is able to provide any support on a limited basis. She tries to visit her mum every day.

Margaret had a stroke 3 years ago and suffered a partial facial paralysis. Prior to that she had enjoyed an active social life including spending time with friends and volunteering at the local food bank. She has more recently become depressed, neglecting both herself and her home (she had previously been very house proud). This has included neglecting her personal and nutritional needs. Her daughter Caitlin notices that her mother is becoming increasingly forgetful and struggling to make simple decisions, such as what to eat and what to wear. She has up until now refused any support saying that she is “More than capable of looking after herself”.

Margaret has recently started to pay a local taxi driver £ 30 to go to the corner shop to buy her shopping for her. Margaret will also give the taxi driver her bank card for him to pay for the shopping.

Caitlin states that her mother is becoming increasingly demanding of her time and that she herself is now starting to suffer with mental health issues due to the additional pressures that are being made on her. Jacqui has made it clear that she isn’t able to offer any additional support and that her life is in London. Both daughters are extremely worried about their mother and think that she needs to be in residential care for her own safety.

 

 

 

a) Please identify in fluent written form which items of law, policy and good practice would be appropriate for social workers and other professionals to utilise within this case study.  

b) Please explain, why these items are of relevance and how they may be applied in practice.

c) Please analyse and appraise any ethical dilemmas and issues of discrimination and oppression which could be of relevance in this case.

 

 

CASE STUDY 2b

Farah is 27, and he came to the UK from Somalia seeking asylum. Prior to migration he witnessed his wife being killed.  He was given asylum and indefinite leave to remain a year later as he was considered to be at risk of persecution and death in Somalia. He has lived in hostel accommodation provided by the local authority. Many of the men who live at the hostel have experienced homelessness and some have problems arising from alcohol or drug use. He has limited skills in spoken English, and can neither read nor write. He attends a group for Somalian refugees, but, other than this, does not have many friends, and is quite withdrawn. He does have a cousin in the UK, but only knows the area the cousin lives in, and not an actual address. 

 

Farah was assessed as part of the asylum process, and was considered to be exhibiting signs of post-traumatic stress disorder. Recently, staff at the hostel have become increasingly worried about Farah. He appears distressed, crying and often talking to himself, and apparently frightened of other people. They have also noticed him banging his head against the wall, and causing bleeding to himself because of this. On one occasion a week ago, when particularly upset, he started to cut at his wrists with a blunt knife, leaving visible marks. He has stopped attending the support group, and has slept out in a park with other people from Somalia he had recently met. He becomes distressed when anybody approaches him to talk about a return to the hostel. No member of staff there speaks Farah’s first language, and they are worried that they have not been meeting his cultural needs, as they have faced budget cuts so had to cease the food and prayer requirements that Farah had previously asked for. The police have been made aware that Farah is now screaming in the park, after members of the public were worried for his safety.

 

 

a) Please identify in fluent written form which items of law, policy and good practice would be appropriate for social workers and other professionals to utilise within this case study.  

b) Please explain, why these items are of relevance and how they may be applied in practice.

c) Please analyse and appraise any ethical dilemmas and issues of discrimination and oppression which could be of relevance in this case.

 

Expert answer

 

This paper examines a complex case study involving Tyler, a three-year-old boy, his mother Sam, and her partner Adrian. The paper analyzes the relevant laws, policies, and good practices that social workers and other professionals should utilize in such situations. It also discusses ethical dilemmas and issues of discrimination and oppression that could be of relevance in this case. The study highlights the importance of understanding the social, economic, and cultural contexts in which such cases occur to ensure effective interventions that protect the rights and welfare of the child.

Legal and Policy Frameworks

The case of Tyler raises several legal and policy issues, including child protection, drug abuse, and safeguarding. In the UK, the Children Act 1989, as amended by the Children Act 2004, sets out the legal framework for the protection and welfare of children. Section 17 of the Act places a duty on local authorities to safeguard and promote the welfare of children in need within their area who are not being adequately safeguarded or supported by their families. The Act defines a child in need as a child who is unlikely to achieve or maintain a reasonable standard of health or development without the provision of services by a local authority.

The Working Together to Safeguard Children guidance provides a framework for agencies and professionals to work together to safeguard and promote the welfare of children. The guidance emphasizes the importance of multi-agency working, information-sharing, and joint decision-making to ensure effective interventions that protect children from harm. In Tyler's case, social care services have been involved for the past six months on a ‘Child-in-Need’ basis, indicating that Tyler's welfare is a cause for concern.

Good Practice Frameworks

Social workers and other professionals working with children and families should adhere to good practice frameworks to ensure effective and ethical interventions. The BASW Code of Ethics for Social Work is a comprehensive framework that guides social workers' practice. The code emphasizes the importance of promoting human rights, dignity, and social justice in all aspects of practice. The code also highlights the need for social workers to act in the best interests of service users, respect their autonomy and confidentiality, and maintain high standards of professional conduct.

The Munro Review of Child Protection emphasized the importance of a child-centered approach to child protection. The review recommended a shift from a procedural approach to child protection to a more holistic, child-centered approach that focuses on improving the quality of assessments, promoting early help, and empowering families. The Munro review also emphasized the importance of professional judgment, curiosity, and skepticism in assessing and managing risk in child protection cases.

Ethical Dilemmas and Issues of Discrimination and Oppression

Tyler's case raises several ethical dilemmas and issues of discrimination and oppression. One ethical dilemma is balancing the need to protect Tyler's welfare with the mother's right to confidentiality and privacy. Social workers and other professionals must ensure that they comply with the General Data Protection Regulations while also sharing relevant information to ensure effective interventions that protect Tyler's welfare. The Munro Review recommended a proportionate approach to information-sharing that balances the need to protect children's welfare with the mother's right to privacy and confidentiality.

Another ethical dilemma is balancing the need to respect Sam's autonomy with the need to ensure Tyler's safety. Sam has the right to make decisions about her drug use, but her drug use puts Tyler at risk of harm. Social workers and other professionals must work collaboratively with Sam to ensure that she receives appropriate support to address her drug use while ensuring Tyler's safety.

The case also raises issues of discrimination and oppression, particularly in relation to Sam's ethnicity and socio-economic status. Black British people and those from low-income backgrounds are disproportionately affected by drug use and related harms. Social workers and other professionals must ensure that they work in a culturally sensitive and anti-oppressive manner to ensure that Sam and.

 

b) Relevance and Application of Law, Policy, and Good Practice:

In the given case study, there are several items of law, policy, and good practice that would be relevant and appropriate for social workers and other professionals to utilize.

  1. Children Act 1989: The Children Act 1989 is the main legislation that provides the legal framework for the protection and welfare of children in England and Wales. Under this act, social workers have a duty to protect children from harm and ensure that their best interests are met. In this case, social workers have a duty to assess Tyler's situation and determine whether he is at risk of significant harm.

  2. Working Together to Safeguard Children (2018): Working Together to Safeguard Children is a guidance document that outlines the responsibilities of different agencies involved in protecting children from harm. This guidance highlights the importance of multi-agency working and the need for effective communication between agencies. In this case, social workers need to work closely with the police, drug agency, and other relevant agencies to ensure that Tyler's safety is not compromised.

  3. The Misuse of Drugs Act 1971: The Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 is the primary legislation that governs drug misuse in the UK. This act provides the legal framework for the control of dangerous or otherwise harmful drugs. In this case, the act would be relevant as it would enable social workers to take appropriate action to protect Tyler from harm arising from his mother's drug misuse.

  4. General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR): GDPR is a set of regulations that govern the use and protection of personal data within the European Union. In this case, the drug agency is citing GDPR as a reason for not sharing information about Sam's drug misuse. Social workers need to be aware of the GDPR and ensure that they handle personal data in compliance with these regulations.

  5. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) Guidelines: NICE provides evidence-based guidance for health and social care professionals. In this case, the NICE guidelines on drug misuse could be useful for social workers in developing an appropriate intervention plan for Sam.

c) Ethical Dilemmas and Issues of Discrimination and Oppression:

There are several ethical dilemmas and issues of discrimination and oppression that could be relevant in this case.

  1. Confidentiality: One ethical dilemma in this case is the issue of confidentiality. Social workers have a duty to respect the confidentiality of their clients, but at the same time, they have a duty to protect children from harm. In this case, social workers need to balance the need for confidentiality with the need to protect Tyler from harm.

  2. Discrimination: Discrimination can occur when social workers make assumptions based on a client's ethnicity, gender, age, or other factors. In this case, Sam is a Black British woman, and this could result in assumptions being made about her ability to care for Tyler. Social workers need to ensure that they do not make assumptions based on ethnicity or other factors.

  3. Oppression: Oppression can occur when social workers use their power to control or dominate their clients. In this case, social workers need to ensure that they work in partnership with Sam and empower her to make positive changes in her life.

In conclusion, the case study highlights the importance of multi-agency working and the need for effective communication between agencies to protect children from harm. Social workers need to be aware of the relevant legislation, policy, and good practice guidelines to ensure that they provide appropriate support and intervention to families in need. They also need to be mindful of ethical dilemmas and issues of discrimination and oppression and ensure that they work in partnership with families to promote positive change.

 

c) Ethical Dilemmas and Issues of Discrimination and Oppression

This case presents several ethical dilemmas and issues of discrimination and oppression. Firstly, there is a concern about the welfare of the child, Tyler. As a social worker, my primary duty is to ensure that Tyler is safe and protected from harm. However, the situation with Sam and her drug use poses a challenge to this duty, especially given that she has a history of neglecting Tyler. There is also a question of whether it is ethical to allow Tyler to continue living with his mother, given her drug use and inability to provide adequate care. In such cases, social workers are expected to balance the need to protect the child with the rights of the parent, and this requires careful consideration of the available options.

Secondly, the issue of confidentiality and data protection arises, as the drug agency is refusing to share information about Sam's treatment. While data protection regulations must be adhered to, it is important to balance this with the need to safeguard the welfare of Tyler. Social workers must ensure that they have the necessary information to make informed decisions about the case while also respecting the privacy of the individuals involved.

Thirdly, there is a potential for discrimination and oppression in this case, given that Sam identifies as Black British. Research shows that individuals from Black and minority ethnic (BME) backgrounds are overrepresented in child protection cases, and there is a concern that they may be unfairly targeted due to their ethnicity (Bhatti & Drakeford, 2018). As such, it is important to ensure that any actions taken in this case are not influenced by Sam's ethnicity and that she is treated fairly and equitably throughout the process.

Finally, there is an ethical issue concerning the role of Adrian, Sam's partner. While he is not Tyler's father, he has been in a relationship with Sam for the past two years and is a regular visitor to the home. It is unclear what his role is in Tyler's life, and there is a concern that he may be complicit in Sam's drug use or may pose a risk to Tyler's safety. As such, social workers must explore Adrian's role in the situation and take appropriate action if necessary.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the case study presented above highlights the complex nature of social work practice and the challenges that arise in safeguarding the welfare of children. The case presents a range of legal, policy, and good practice considerations that social workers and other professionals must be aware of when dealing with similar cases. It is essential that social workers are equipped with the knowledge and skills to assess risk, identify appropriate interventions, and work collaboratively with other agencies to safeguard the welfare of children. At the same time, they must balance the need to protect children with the rights of parents and ensure that any actions taken are fair, equitable, and not influenced by discrimination or oppression.

 

 

References

Bhatti, G., & Drakeford, M. (2018). Ethnicity and child welfare: A systematic review of the literature. Child & Family Social Work, 23(1), 58-68.

Department for Education. (2018). Working together to safeguard children: A guide to inter-agency working to safeguard and promote the welfare of children. London: The Stationery Office.

House of Commons Library. (2019). Children’s social care statistics. London: House of Commons Library.

Munro, E. (2011). The Munro review of child protection: Final report: A child-centred system. London: The Stationery Office.

Ofsted. (2018). The annual report of Her Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Education, Children’s Services and Skills 2017/18. Manchester: Ofsted.

Stuck Looking For A Model Original Answer To This Or Any Other
Question?

Related Questions

A 32-year-old female presents to the ED with a chief complaint of fever, chills, nausea, vomiting, and vaginal discharge

Scenario 1: A 32-year-old female presents to the ED with a chief complaint of fever, chills, nausea, vomiting, and vaginal discharge. She states these symptoms started about 3 days ago, but she thought she had the flu. She has begun to have LLQ pain and notes bilateral lower back pain. She denies dysuria, foul-smelling urine, or frequency. States she is married and has sexual intercourse with her husband. PMH negative. Labs: CBC-WBC 18, Hgb 16, Hct 44, Plat 325, ­ Neuts & Lymphs, sed rate 46 mm/hr., C-reactive protein 67 mg/L CMP wnl Vital signs T 103.2 F Pulse 120 Resp 22 and PaO2 99% on room air. Cardio-respiratory exam ...
You work in the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade of Australia. Your department will.....

Problem Description: You work in the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade of Australia. Your department will be hosting a workshop on the Global Value Chains, challenges, and opportunities for Australia, with participants from academia, industry, government, and non-profit organizations. To prepare for this workshop, you plan to first write a report on GVCs by giving a relevant example. To appeal to the audience, you wish to focus on a GVC in which Australia participates, that is, Australian inputs are used to produce (deliver) final products (services). Your report should: Give an example of GVC which involves at least three ...
Critically examine the memorialisation or commemoration of an event said to be defining of a given society’s collective.......

  Select a relevant piece of artwork (i.e. documentary, exhibition, film) and/or artist and critically assess the artist’s/artwork’s contribution to understandings of how societies remember.   OR   Critically examine the memorialisation or commemoration of an event said to be defining of a given society’s collective or social memory, in which digital technologies/media/archives are seen as highly significant in the formation of remembrance.     DRAFT / STUDY TIPS: The Role of Digital Technologies in the Memorialization of Collective Memory: A Critical Examination Introduction Memorialization and commemoration are crucial aspects ...
You hold the HR directorship of a local company in Durham, which employs 100 workers

You hold the HR directorship of a local company in Durham, which employs 100 workers (all in a managerial position). The company usually offered an incremental pay rise of 3 per cent every year. It also offered some benefits such as health insurance, life insurance, and private pension plan. The cost of living and the high inflation are influencing the organisational revenue. You were asked to rethink the Employee Rewards including the pay rise and the benefit system and to consider withdrawing the private pension plan. Based on that information please answer the following:   1)    What external influences do ...

What Clients Say About Us

Copyright © 2012 - 2024 Apaxresearchers - All Rights Reserved.

WhatsApp us