Call/WhatsApp/Text: +44 20 3289 5183

Question: Critics of the communications industry claim that PR is not a profession. Critically analyse this view to come to a clear conclusion.

03 May 2023,7:55 AM

 

  1. Bernays, considered one of the fathers of PR, said that a PR professional is “an applied social scientist who advises clients or employers on the social attitudes or actions to take to win support of the publics upon whom the survival of the client depends." Critically analyse Bernays’s statement to make a clear conclusion. 

 

  1. L’Etang (2006a) argues that two-way symmetrical model is partisan because the power tends to reside with the organisation and therefore mutual relationship between the organisation and its publics is impossible to achieve. Is this true in the post-pandemic world? Critically analyse L’Etang’s stance to make a clear conclusion.

 

  1. Critics of the communications industry claim that PR is not a profession. Critically analyse this view to come to a clear conclusion.

 

  1. CSR and ESG are the same means organisations use to boost customer loyalty, but they don’t bring about a meaningful change to the ways organisations operate. Critically analyse this view to come to a clear conclusion.

 

 

https://apaxresearchers.com/storage/files/2023/05/03/9667-4M9_11_48_25_lecture-8-internal-communications-tagged-1.pdf

https://apaxresearchers.com/storage/files/2023/05/03/9667-y5S_11_48_12_lecture-9-non-commercial-pr-tagged-1.pdf

https://apaxresearchers.com/storage/files/2023/05/03/9667-hvX_11_48_02_lecture-1-what-is-pr-canvas-tagged.pdf

https://apaxresearchers.com/storage/files/2023/05/03/9667-o3B_11_47_52_lecture-2-key-concepts-of-pr-tagged.pdf

Expert answer

 

Public Relations (PR) is a field that has gained tremendous attention in recent years due to its critical role in shaping public opinion and maintaining the image of individuals, companies, and organizations. While PR has emerged as an essential component of modern-day business operations, it has also been the subject of controversy, with critics questioning whether it qualifies as a profession.

Public Relations (PR) is a field that has gained tremendous attention in recent years due to its critical role in shaping public opinion and maintaining the image of individuals, companies, and organizations. While PR has emerged as an essential component of modern-day business operations, it has also been the subject of controversy, with critics questioning whether it qualifies as a profession. This paper aims to critically analyze this view to come to a clear conclusion on whether PR can be regarded as a profession.

What is Public Relations? Public Relations is a strategic communication process that aims to build mutually beneficial relationships between an organization and its stakeholders. These stakeholders may include customers, employees, investors, government officials, and the general public. The main objective of PR is to create and maintain a positive image of the organization in the eyes of its stakeholders, through a range of activities such as media relations, event planning, crisis management, and community engagement.

PR as a Profession One of the key debates surrounding PR is whether it can be regarded as a profession. The definition of a profession can be subjective, but it generally refers to an occupation that requires specialized knowledge, skills, and training, and is recognized by society as having a unique status and purpose. In this sense, PR can be regarded as a profession, as it requires a range of specialized skills and knowledge, and involves a significant amount of training and education.

Education and Training To become a PR professional, individuals must typically have a degree in communication, journalism, marketing, or a related field. Many universities offer PR-specific programs that provide students with a comprehensive understanding of the field, including theoretical concepts, practical skills, and ethical considerations. In addition, many PR professionals pursue certifications such as the Accreditation in Public Relations (APR) offered by the Public Relations Society of America (PRSA), which requires extensive knowledge of PR principles and practices and adherence to a strict code of ethics.

Ethical Considerations Another important aspect of a profession is adherence to a code of ethics. PR professionals are expected to adhere to ethical standards in their interactions with stakeholders, including truthfulness, transparency, and respect for the privacy and confidentiality of individuals and organizations. Professional associations such as PRSA have established codes of ethics that guide the behavior of PR professionals, and violations can result in disciplinary action.

Impact on Society Finally, the impact of a profession on society is an important consideration. PR has a significant impact on society, as it can shape public opinion and influence decision-making processes. This influence can be positive or negative, depending on the actions of PR professionals. For example, a PR campaign that promotes a social cause or encourages community engagement can have a positive impact on society, while a campaign that misleads the public or promotes unethical behavior can have a negative impact.

Criticism of PR as a Profession Despite the arguments in favor of PR as a profession, critics have raised several objections to this view. One of the main criticisms is that PR is too focused on serving the interests of clients, rather than the broader public interest. Critics argue that PR professionals are often tasked with promoting the image of their clients, even if it involves misleading the public or engaging in unethical behavior. This focus on serving the interests of clients can be seen as a conflict of interest, which undermines the status of PR as a profession.

Another criticism of PR as a profession is that it lacks a unified body of knowledge and standards. While PR professionals may have a range of skills and knowledge in areas such as media relations, crisis management, and event planning, there is no unified body of knowledge that defines the field. This lack of standardization can make it difficult for PR professionals to be recognized as a profession by society.

Finally, critics argue that PR is too closely aligned with marketing and advertising, which are not considered professions. Marketing and advertising are often viewed as industries focused on promoting products and services, rather than building mutually beneficial relationships with stakeholders. This perception can reflect poorly on the status of PR as a profession, as it can be seen as a subset of marketing and advertising, rather than a distinct field with its own set of skills and principles.

Counterarguments for PR as a Profession Despite the criticisms, there are counterarguments that suggest PR can be regarded as a profession. One argument is that the focus on serving the interests of clients is not unique to PR, and is common across many professions, such as law and medicine. In these fields, professionals are often hired to represent the interests of their clients, even if it involves engaging in controversial or unethical practices. The key difference is that in PR, professionals are expected to adhere to a code of ethics that promotes transparency and honesty in their interactions with stakeholders.

Another counterargument is that while there may not be a unified body of knowledge that defines PR, there are established principles and best practices that guide the work of PR professionals. These principles and practices include strategies for effective communication, crisis management, and stakeholder engagement. Furthermore, the field of PR is constantly evolving, with new trends and practices emerging as technology and social media platforms continue to shape the way organizations interact with their stakeholders.

Conclusion In conclusion, the question of whether PR qualifies as a profession is complex and multifaceted. While there are criticisms of PR as a profession, such as the focus on serving the interests of clients and the lack of a unified body of knowledge, there are also counterarguments that suggest PR can be regarded as a profession. These counterarguments highlight the specialized knowledge, training, and ethical considerations required of PR professionals, as well as the impact of PR on society. Ultimately, whether PR is regarded as a profession depends on one's interpretation of the definition of a profession. However, based on the evidence presented in this paper, it can be concluded that PR has many of the attributes of a profession and plays a critical role in shaping public opinion and maintaining the image of organizations in today's society.

Stuck Looking For A Model Original Answer To This Or Any Other
Question?


Related Questions

What Clients Say About Us

WhatsApp us